SmCo Vs. NdFeB: Which Magnet Performs Better at High Temperatures?

In industries such as aerospace, automotive, and energy, components often operate in harsh environments where elevated temperatures can significantly affect material performance. Magnets are no exception. Among the most commonly used permanent magnets are Samarium Cobalt (SmCo) and Neodymium Iron Boron (NdFeB), both of which belong to the rare earth magnet family. However, they respond differently to heat, and selecting the right type is crucial for ensuring long-term reliability, magnetic strength retention, and overall system performance. SmCo magnets are known for their excellent thermal and chemical stability, while NdFeB magnets offer superior magnetic power at room temperature but are more sensitive to heat and corrosion. This article explores how these two magnet types perform under high-temperature conditions by comparing their properties, analyzing real-world applications, and providing actionable guidance for engineers and designers. Whether you’re developing electric motors, high-speed sensors, or precision aerospace components, understanding these differences can help optimize both performance and cost.

At Heeger Magnet, we specialize in samarium cobalt magnets and neodymium iron boron magnets, ensuring optimal performance for industrial and scientific applications.

What Are SmCo and NdFeB Magnets?

SmCo and NdFeB magnets are both strong permanent magnets made from rare earth elements. While NdFeB magnets are known for their superior magnetic strength at room temperature, SmCo magnets offer greater thermal and corrosion stability.

 Comprehensive Properties of SmCo vs. NdFeB Magnets:

How Do High Temperatures Affect Magnetic Performance?

Heat reduces a magnet’s ability to retain its magnetic field. As temperature increases, magnetic domains become unstable, leading to a drop in remanence (Br) and coercivity (Hci). In extreme cases, permanent demagnetization can occur. This makes thermal resistance a critical factor when selecting magnets for high-temperature environments.

Table: General Impact of Temperature on Magnetic Properties:

Which Magnet Maintains Magnetism Better at High Temperatures?

SmCo magnets maintain their magnetic properties more reliably at elevated temperatures. NdFeB magnets, while stronger at room temperature, suffer significant performance loss as temperatures rise.

Magnetic Property Retention at Various Temperatures:

Explore our high-quality samarium cobalt magnets and neodymium iron boron magnets.

Why Is SmCo More Thermally Stable Than NdFeB?

SmCo magnets have a more thermally stable crystal structure, making their magnetic domains less susceptible to heat-induced fluctuations. Additionally, they are less reactive with oxygen, reducing the risk of oxidation at high temperatures. Their low temperature coefficient ensures consistent performance over a broader temperature range.

Can NdFeB Magnets Be Used in High-Temperature Applications?

Yes, but with limitations. NdFeB magnets can be engineered for high-temperature resistance using specific grades. These high-temperature NdFeB magnets are designated by suffixes such as H, SH, UH, and EH.

High-Temperature Grades of NdFeB Magnets:

What Are the Pros and Cons of SmCo and NdFeB at High Temperatures?

Each magnet has its own advantages and limitations when exposed to elevated temperatures. Understanding these trade-offs is essential for making the right material choice in engineering and design.

 Pros and Cons in High-Temperature Environments

SmCo Magnets:

✅ Pros:

• Excellent thermal stability
• High coercivity
• Naturally corrosion-resistant

❌ Cons:

• High cost
• Brittle and difficult to machine

NdFeB Magnets:

✅ Pros:

• Strongest magnetic force
• Lower cost
• Easy to manufacture in complex shapes

❌ Cons:

• Poor thermal resistance
• Requires coating to prevent corrosion

How to Choose the Right Magnet for High-Temperature Use?

Choosing the right magnet depends on several factors, including thermal performance, magnetic strength requirements, mechanical and chemical stability, environmental exposure, and overall cost. Material selection should align with the specific needs of the application to avoid failures under thermal stress.

Selection Guide: Key Considerations

• Operating Temperature: SmCo is better above 200°C; NdFeB can be used below that range if properly graded.
• Magnetic Strength Needs: NdFeB is the strongest at room temperature.
• Environmental Factors: For corrosive or oxidizing environments, SmCo is more stable.
• Budget Constraints: NdFeB is more economical for most general applications.
• Mechanical Durability: NdFeB is less brittle and easier to process into complex shapes.

Request a custom quote for high-quality samarium cobalt magnet and neodymium iron boron magnet.

Where Are SmCo and NdFeB Magnets Used in High-Temperature Conditions?

SmCo and NdFeB magnets are widely used across industries, and each type is suited for different high-temperature scenarios depending on their unique properties.

Application Examples: SmCo vs. NdFeB in Real-World High-Temperature Environments. Real-world applications help illustrate why one magnet type might be preferred over the other when operating under elevated temperatures:

• Aerospace turbines: SmCo for heat and corrosion resistance
• Electric vehicle motors: NdFeB (EH or AH grade) for compact high power
• Industrial sensors: SmCo for reliability in continuous high heat
• Medical equipment: NdFeB for precision magnetic assemblies under moderate heat

FAQ

Conclusion

If your application demands continuous operation at temperatures above 200°C, SmCo magnets stand out as the dependable choice thanks to their outstanding thermal stability and inherent resistance to oxidation. Conversely, for designs that emphasize maximum magnetic strength at room or moderate temperatures while keeping costs manageable, NdFeB magnets remain the preferred solution. Ultimately, selecting the ideal magnet requires carefully balancing performance, environmental conditions, and budget constraints. Heeger Magnet is committed to providing premium-quality SmCo and NdFeB magnets, engineered to meet the rigorous demands of various industries and deliver consistent, reliable performance under challenging conditions.

Looking for high-quality samarium cobalt magnets and neodymium iron boron magnets. Contact us today!